My pick is Zeke the Plumber from Salute Your Shorts. I was inspired by
Matt Kobylarek for this one. Zeke is, without a doubt, scarier than any Are You Afraid of the Dark episode and he's super creepy.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/39cb9/39cb9cb6fd10cee5733498f237fc67d619a10071" alt=""
Make a Zeke.
Tape it up.
Matt Kobylarek can pick next week since he inspired me.